Legs in the garden
The task (for students)
In a garden there are only birds and dogs. Birds have 2 legs, dogs have 4 legs. Altogether you can count 14 legs. How many birds and how many dogs could be in the garden? Find every possibility.
Learning goals
- Use repeated addition and counting in 2s and 4s
- Explore several solutions and argue that there are no more
Materials
- One whiteboard per group
Hints if a group gets stuck
- Draw the animals as sticks for legs. What happens if you swap one dog for birds?
- Could there be 4 dogs?
Extensions when a group is done
- There must be at least one of each animal. Which possibilities are left?
- Spiders arrive too (8 legs). How many possibilities are there now for 14 legs?
- With birds and dogs, what is the fewest and the most animals that make 20 legs?
Teacher notes
- Some groups guess and check; others find the swap pattern (1 dog = 2 birds). Highlight both in consolidation.
- Ask 'how do you know you have them all?' instead of confirming answers.
Show solutions (for the teacher)
- Dogs/birds: 0/7, 1/5, 2/3, 3/1 – four possibilities (three if at least one of each).
- With spiders (14 legs): 6 possibilities – the 4 above plus 1 spider with 0 dogs/3 birds or 1 dog/1 bird.
- 20 legs: fewest animals = 5 dogs (5 animals), most = 10 birds (10 animals).
Licence: CC BY 4.0 – credit Tænketavlen. Task id: tt-002.